Multibagger penny stock below Rs 20: RoE of 358 per cent and trading at 1.42x PE; answering the mystery!
Despite reporting an operating loss of 0.25 crore in the recent quarterly performance, it boasts an astounding RoE of 358 per cent. How is it possible for a loss-making company to exhibit such a high RoE?
Introduction:
In the intricate landscape of investments, discerning investors seek hidden gems that not only promise a good margin of safety but also exhibit significant growth potential. Key metrics like Price-to-Earnings ratio (P/E) and Return on Equity (RoE) often act as compass points for these investors, guiding them towards stocks with promising profitability and efficiency. This article delves into the intriguing case of Modern Steel Ltd (MSL), a penny stock trading below Rs 20, possessing a remarkable 358% RoE and a modest P/E of 1.42x.
Company Overview:
Established in 1974 by Mr. Amarjit Goyal, MSL is listed on the Bombay Stock Exchange and currently managed by Mr. Krishan Kumar Goyal, the son of the founder. Specializing in the manufacture of low-alloy and carbon-steel-rolled products, MSL caters to commercial vehicles, passenger vehicles, two-wheelers, and engineering companies.
The RoE Puzzle:
Despite reporting an operating loss of 0.25 crore in the recent quarterly performance, MSL boasts an astounding RoE of 358 per cent. How is it possible for a loss-making company to exhibit such a high RoE? Several scenarios shed light on this paradox:
1. Past Profits and Reserves:
- If the company accumulated profits and reserves in previous years, it might still have positive shareholder equity, even if it incurs a net loss in the current period.
2. One-Time Adjustments:
- Net losses may result from one-time non-cash charges, such as asset impairments or restructuring costs, masking the operational profitability and artificially inflating RoE.
3. Deferred Tax Assets:
- Accrued deferred tax assets over time can bolster the equity base, creating a higher RoE despite ongoing operational losses.
4. Recent Equity Infusion:
- If the company recently raised capital by issuing new shares, the expanded equity base can mitigate the impact of net losses on RoE.
Digging Deeper:
While mathematical RoE may appear positive despite losses, investors must delve deeper to evaluate the true profitability of the business. Sustainable high RoE derives from consistent profitability rather than financial engineering.
Strategic Shift:
In a recent update, MSL revealed that it no longer engages in manufacturing operations, having sold its plant in Mandi Gobindgarh (Punjab). Despite this, the financial statements are prepared under the going concern concept, hinting at the management's intention to embark on new commercial activities.
Conclusion:
MSL's stock has surged over 350% in the last three years, marking it as a mega multibagger. However, investors are advised to adopt a holistic perspective, considering the intricacies of the company's financials and strategic decisions. In the ever-evolving landscape of investments, thorough analysis remains paramount for making informed decisions.
Disclaimer: The article is for informational purposes only and not investment advice.
DSIJ offers a service 'Multibagger Pick" with recommendations for multibagger stocks based on research and analysis to help subscribers make informed investment decisions. If this interests you, then do download the service details pdf here